The 2023 baseball season has proven to be a highly disappointing one for the New York Yankees. Although they managed to break a nine-game losing streak recently, their struggles continued as they faced another defeat today, resulting in a season record of 61-66. This performance places them at the bottom of the American League East division, trailing the fourth-place Red Sox by 6.5 games. Furthermore, they find themselves 10 games away from securing the final Wild Card spot in the American League. FanGraphs’ calculations indicate that their chances of making the playoffs stand at a mere 0.3%. This outcome is far from what was anticipated for a team that entered the season with aspirations of contending, coupled with one of the highest payrolls in the league.

Brian Cashman, the Yankees’ General Manager, took the opportunity to speak with the media yesterday, openly acknowledging the evident struggles the team has faced. In a conversation reported by Brendan Kuty of The Athletic, Cashman characterized the season as a “disaster” and expressed a sense of embarrassment. Addressing the fans’ frustration, some of whom called for his dismissal, Cashman defended his position by highlighting the team’s overall successful track record. He recognized the challenges inherent in the sport, emphasizing its unpredictable nature by stating, “Nothing is guaranteed.”

Indeed, Cashman’s tenure as General Manager since February 1998 has yielded a strong overall performance. The Yankees have managed to avoid finishing a season below .500 during this time, with their last losing season dating back to 1992. Since 1995, they have only missed the postseason on four occasions and have clinched the World Series championship five times.

However, despite these achievements, some fans feel that the team’s recent successes do not adequately measure up, especially when compared to the dominant period under Cashman’s leadership. A significant portion of those five titles were secured between 1996 and 2000, with the most recent victory occurring in 2009. While the Yankees have consistently reached the playoffs in the past six years, they have struggled to advance beyond the American League Championship Series for over a decade. Additionally, their streak of consecutive winning seasons spanning 30 years is currently at risk in the 2023 season. Whether Cashman will retain his current role remains uncertain, and he offered little clarity on the matter, suggesting that the decision would ultimately be made by someone higher up, potentially referring to chairman Hal Steinbrenner.

Evaluating how much responsibility Cashman should bear for the team’s challenges in 2023 is a subject of debate within certain circles. Injuries have undeniably played a substantial role in the team’s performance, sidelining key players for extended periods. Notably, the starting rotation has been without Frankie Montas for the entire season, while Nestor Cortes and Carlos Rodón have struggled with injuries, resulting in subpar performances when they have been able to play. On the offensive side, players like Aaron Judge and Anthony Rizzo have grappled with significant injury issues, leading to periods of absence or diminished performance, or both.

Proponents of Cashman could argue that the team’s strong roster on paper was undermined by unexpected injuries, a factor beyond their control. However, critics could counter that injuries are a universal challenge in sports and part of a General Manager’s responsibility is constructing a roster that can withstand the ups and downs of player health over a season.

Irrespective of the causes, it appears that the organization will consider a wide range of potential changes in the upcoming months. Cashman acknowledged this, indicating that a thorough evaluation of all aspects of the team’s operations will occur, encompassing both himself and manager Aaron Boone. He stated that the team is not content with the current state, believing that they can perform better, and expressed a commitment to improvement.

The franchise’s response to this underwhelming season will be closely observed in the coming weeks and months. Historically, the Yankees have been known for their aggressive pursuit of competitiveness and willingness to invest in player acquisitions. Even before the offseason begins, the team’s 2024 payroll is already substantial, and they are nearing the competitive balance tax threshold. These figures, however, do not factor in arbitration salaries for certain players. Given these financial considerations, the team will likely have a busy offseason as they address their roster and performance concerns.

Looking ahead to 2024, several key areas will need attention. The starting rotation boasts a promising front three with Gerrit Cole, Carlos Rodón, and Nestor Cortes, provided they are in good health. However, another strong pitcher could be beneficial, considering potential uncertainties. The lineup presents its own set of challenges, with the team collectively struggling to hit and score runs effectively. Injuries to players like Aaron Judge and Anthony Rizzo have certainly impacted this performance, but underwhelming showings from veterans such as DJ LeMahieu and Giancarlo Stanton have also contributed. LeMahieu and Stanton’s contracts and ages present complications should the team decide to part ways.

Moreover, upcoming free agency will create additional gaps in the lineup, with players like Harrison Bader, Isiah Kiner-Falefa, and possibly Josh Donaldson set to explore the market. These potential departures will require strategic decisions to maintain team strength.

The Yankees seem poised to use the remainder of the current season to provide opportunities for younger players. Recent promotions of Everson Pereira and Oswald Peraza, along with the potential addition of catching prospect Austin Wells, reflect this approach. Wells, regarded as a top 100 prospect, could offer fresh talent to the catching position. With the expanded rosters in September, the team could utilize this opportunity to evaluate Wells and potentially add him to the 40-man roster.

In conclusion, the New York Yankees are facing a critical juncture as they navigate a disappointing 2023 season. While challenges abound, their historical resilience and determination to compete suggest that they will make strategic moves to regain their competitive edge and strive for success in the seasons to come.